- Public opinion - the sum of individual attitudes about the government, policies, and issues
- Critical to the effective represrentation - leading vs following public opinion
- To what extent do americans have meaninful opinions on the issues?
- To what extent do they have basic knowledge of American government?
- Education levels, race, ethnicity
- Do they need knowledge of American government to form meaningful opinions?
- Wisdom of crowds - collective rationality
- How do americans form political opinions?
- Individual experience
- Gut rationality
- Political party identification
- Effect of the algorithm
- Pushes candidates onto your feed
- Social networks
- People follow their friends
- Demographics stay basically the same across candidates
Measuring Public Opinion
- Direct communication from constituents (letters, calls, emails, and town hall events)
- Rare and does ont reflect the opinions of typical voters - tend to hold the strongest views
- Elections
- However, many eligible voters do not vote
- Turnout:
- Greatest: general eelections, presidential, gubernatorial, midterm, mayoral
- Least: primaries, - most dedicated and hold strongest views
- Up or down opinion is not specific
- Trend for november election: many more republican retirements than democratic
- Not going to go well in november
- Anticipating a wave election of Democrats
Measuring Public Opinion: Polling
- Focus group - small group of individuals assembled for a conversation, led by a moderator
- Scientific poll - polling a select usbset of a constituency with carefully written questions
- Who to sample? who will vote? registered vs likely voters
- Representative sample reflects demographics of population
- Cell phones vs land line dialing, who picks up the phone
- Internet polls arent random and are voluntary and unscientific
- Random selection - randomly choosing to now over represent any group
- Weightings adjust results based on differences between the percentages of specific groups in survery and demographic of larger populaiton
- Margin of error +− a certain number
- Mass survey - 1500 participants, larger than national polls. Larger polls increase certainty at a cost
Generational and Life Ctcle Effects
- Political opinions change over the course of a lifetime
- Life Cycle Effect
- Impact of a persons age and stage in life on his or her political views
- Generational effect
- Impact of historical events experienced by a generation upon their political views
- Great Depression, WW2, Vietnam, 9/11, Great Recession, Me Too
- Older people are far more poltiically engaged than younger people
Globalization
- US is dominant following WW2
- Multinaitonal corporations
- NGOs
- IGOs
- Globalized economy
- US Free trade
- Bilateral agreements
- Regional agreements
- North America
- NAFTA - US, Canada, Mexico - Clinton
- USMCA - US,C,M 2020 - Trump
- Asia
- TPP - Trans Pacific Partnership - 2016 Obama
- Globalization
- Countries come together to increase trade and trade agreements
- Bilateral, regional
- Why do multinational companies want to increase their size?
- Access to new consumers, allows them to decrease price
- US Multinational Corporations
- Coca cola, disney, berkshire hathaway, mcdonalds, the nba
- Global footprint increases amount of money company will make
- Outsourcing
- Moving labor to foreign countries
- Cheaper, but doesnt increase market share, shipping costs
- Lower costs of living and lower safety centers
- Causes pollution, exploitation, takes jobs from other countries
- Cost of goods are lower
- Free trade brings down cost
Effects of Globalization
- Encourage democratization and transparency
- EU required a certain level of democracy for admission and make gov decisions transparent
- Trade benefits are motivation
- NGOs report on human rights abuses
- Tech advancements make protest easier and hiding abuses more difficult
- More extreme views can unify criminal enterprises online
- Outsourcing
- Corporations race to the bottom to move production where labor costs are cheaper and regulations are more lax
- Cultural homogenization
Measuring Public Opinion
- Direct communication from constituents (letters, calls, emails, town hall events)
- Rare and does not reflect the opinions of typical voters, tend to hold the strongest views
- Elections
- However, many eligible voters do not vote
- Turnout is greatest for general elections and primaries
- Up or down opinion, not specific
Polling
- Focus group - small group of individuals assembled for a conversation, led by a moderator
- Scientific poll - polling a select subset of a constituency with carefully written questions (question order, wording is important)
- Who to sample? who will vote
- Representative sample
- How to sample, phones, etc
- Internet polls, not random, voluntary, unscientific
- Random selection in order to not over or under represent a group
- Weighting - adjust results based on percentages of groups
- Margin of error - plus minus a few percent
- Mass survey - about 1500 partipants, larger polls increase certainty at a cpst
Surveys
- Surveys that allow anyone to participate are not random or scientific and are not reliable
- Straw poll - tally of support among people attending an event
- Entrance survey - poll of people coming into an event
- Exit poll - survey conducted outside a polling place, asked who they voted for and why
- Information held until all polls close
- Used to understand voting patterns
- Benchmark poll - taken at the beginning of a political campaign
- Tracking poll - determines level of support for a candidate or issue over time
- Push poll - disguised as a survey, presents voters with negative views of opponent
- Any poll - How truthful are the responses? distrust of media, 2016 election
Patterns within American public opinion
- Predictors of public opinion
- Party affiliation
- Gender
- Gender gap - american women are more likely to vote for the democratic party and men for the republican party
- women tend to vote in higher percentages than men but this is a turnout issue and not a matter of a gender gap
- Race and ethnicity
- Socioeconomics
Public Opinion and Governing
- Personal responsibility and work opportunity act of 1996 - contained many popular reforms to welfare
- 5 year limit on benefits, work requirements for welfare after 2 years
- Tax cuts and jobs act of 2017 - 30R% approval
- Big Beautiful Bill - 38% approval
- Tariffs - 36% approval
- Long term benefits, especially economic favoranolity in media and public may catch up
- Risky, continued unpopularity and anti-incumbency sentiment
- Legislation may be important to donors